Skip to main content

The difference between "teaching" and "telling"... and why we should question authority

A very interesting article from Michael J. O’Loughlin of America Magazine. It's worth your time to read it.


The article focuses on questions young people were asking Boston's Auxiliary Bishop Mark O'Connell... not an unusual thing when you have a bishop talking with Confirmation candidates about their faith. When asked about their feelings on the event I was struck by one of the responses: "One person told him that bishops should teach, not listen."

This comment cut me, as a catechist, to the core. Yes, it is a bishop's primary mission to teach. But the operative word here is "teach" not "tell." "Teaching" people is not the same as "telling" them what to do. "Teaching" by it's very nature involves a dialogue between the teacher and the student. We call it the "Socratic method" employed by the great Greek philosopher Socrates and embraced by the Paris University movement of the Middle Ages. And it is still very much alive today at every academic level.

But here's the rub, and the real issue being raised by this one person... "Teaching" as I have described requires that the student also participate in the process... to take the information, processes it, and form their own conscience (as is true with all Catholic teaching). There are, unfortunately, too many people who don't want to go to that effort. They prefer simply to be "told" what to do. While this might seem easier, and is the path of least resistance, it has a major problem: It has you giving up your own free will, and in essence, subjugating yourself to an authority other than Christ.

But here's the most important point: When the time comes for us to stand before Christ and be judged, it's all on us alone. We won't be able to pass it off on someone else. Put another way, to say, "I was just following orders" is not a sufficient excuse.

I often tell people that I think being Catholic today is a lot harder than it was before the Second Vatican Council. Back then we were taught that if we just followed what Father or Sister had to say, we would be OK... Our salvation was assured. But as we now know, that's not enough. We have to be active and conscious participants in our own salvation, and decide for ourselves what is right or wrong... and WHY. And thankfully, we also have God's mercy, because none of us are perfect.

A Postscript:
Now before I start getting a lot of comments reminding me that in this case a bishop, by the nature of their office, speaks for Christ and his Church, I would simply remind people that a bishop, while speaking for Christ, is not himself Christ. I have met and known a number of bishops, and been awed by their charism and wisdom. But even they would say that while their office gives them a certain authority, they remain flawed human being like the rest of us and subject to mistakes. And we, who owe a fealty to our pastors and bishops, should be even more attentive to the need of forming our own consciences. To be true students and engage in dialog with our teachers. Only then can true learning take place.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

3rd Sunday of Ordinary Time - Cycle C

“In the beginning there was the Word…”  These are the dramatic opening lines from the Gospel according to John, and though we will not be reading from John’s Gospel this Sunday, these words ring true for our readings for this 3rd Sunday of Ordinary time.  The people are in the midst of something new, a new beginning that, as our readings will show, begin with The Word… The Word for the 3rd Sunday of Ordinary Time Nehemiah 8:2-4a, 5-6, 8-10 Psalm 19:8, 9, 10, 15 1 Corinthians 12:12-30 (or 1 Corinthians 12:12-14, 27) Luke 1:1-4; 4:14-21 Our first reading is from the book of the Prophet Nehemiah.  Nehemiah, along with the priest/prophet Ezra, are the architects of the Restoration of Israel.  Their great Exile in Babylon is over and through the grace of the Persian King, Cyrus the Great, Israel is free to return to their land, to rebuild the Temple and to rebuild their lives as the people of God.  In an effort to guild them in this new beginning, Nehemiah and Ezra g...

Feast of the Presentation of the Lord

February 2nd is the date chosen by the Church to celebrate the Feast of the Presentation of the Lord.  When a significant feast day falls on a Sunday, the Church sets aside the readings for that normal week to celebrate the feast with these special readings: The Word for the Feast of the Presentation of the Lord Malachi 3:1-43 Psalm 24: 7, 8, 9, 10 Hebrews 2:14-18 Luke 2:22-40 or 2:22-32 While the Catholic Church today refers to this day as the Feast of the Presentation of the Lord, traditionally it has also been called the Presentation of Jesus at the Temple, Candlemas, the Feast of the Purification of the Virgin, and the Meeting of the Lord .  Prior to the Second Vatican Council, Candlemas was a time where beeswax candles were blessed for use throughout the year, a tradition still followed in some parish communities.  Today the celebration focuses more on the prophecy of Simeon, and Pope John Paul II chose it as a time for renewal of religious vows (not to be confused...

8th Sunday of Ordinary Time - Cycle C

As with last week’s readings, our readings for the 8th Sunday of Ordinary Time are usually passed over for other feast days, but since Easter is somewhat late this year, we get to finish out this stretch of Ordinary Time with some readings we rarely get to hear during Sunday Mass: The Word for the 8th Sunday of Ordinary Time Sirach 27:4-7 Psalm 92:2-3, 13-14, 15-16 1 Corinthians 15:54-58 Luke 6:39-45 Our first reading comes from the book of Sirach, also known as the Wisdom of Ben Sira, a great sage from Jerusalem who embraced the Wisdom tradition.  The work was originally finished around 175 BCE and was later translated into Greek by the author’s grandson sometime after 117 BCE during the Jewish diaspora that flourished in the later Ancient Greek Empire.  Since our earliest manuscripts for this book were found in Greek, it does not hold the same canonical status for Jews and Protestants, but more recent archeological finds have verified its Hebrew origins.  Like all Wisdo...